Wich one is better?

[Kuroro]

I want your opinion about what is better.If you have to choose one,wich one would you pick?

DC-9 dancing lady
nano radiation,fully t4 moded except for a t3 mag,mastered:1,10 crit mult
x0,95 reload
x1,15 crit mult
x1,25 crit mult
10 ego power recharge on critical kill
x1,10 dmg

dmg 2658
fire rate 15,7
mag 84
reload 1,3
crit mult 2,6
bloom 0,07

or

Blackened hellfire tachmag
nano fire,fully t4 moded,recharges life and shield...mastered:+10% crit mult to incoming tarjets
x1,05 mag
x0,90 reload
x1,05 dmg
10% ego power recharge on a critical kill
x1,10 dmg

dmg 1709
fire rate 25.0
mag 83
reload 1,3
crit mult 2.0
bloom 0,11

important point:the dancing lady is lv 4995 and the hf tachmag is lv 4655

[Gai]

Dancing Lady, can't beat those crit rolls lol.

[Kuroro]

yeah it has 2,6 crit mult >.< but it does not recharges life as hf tachmag does...the saturnalia synergy is not so good i guess.its difficult.i was thinking about to trade the dancing lady but i like it a lot,i dont know if i should keep it or trade since i have the hf tachmag too...

[Gai]

Just keep both, use the dancing lady in a pvp set and tachmag in a pve set.

[Kuroro]

well i want a carving knife for pvp.my idea was trade the dancing lady+milking maid fully t4 moddedd+scrip for the carver...but i liked the dancing lady a lot so i dont know what to do >.<

[Dixie Cougar]

DL is going to do a lot more for you than a knife ever will. Use the DL (rad) for shielded or armored enemies and the TMP for raiders, mutants, and the like, or if you just need a weapon that will heal you. If you can't crit reliably with the DL, look into a needler.

If I had to pick one I would go with the DL simply because it's viable against nearly any enemy in the game. The TMP will be relatively weak against volge/DM and the like at high threat levels, even with Flash Point on.

[stefb42]

Don't trade those for a carving knife, you will likely regret it, the carving knife, though novel is somewhat underwhelming and a bit of a disappointment in all honesty, it has a synergy you cant get mods for so the syn is pointless, the blade is invisible most of the time, and it doesn't strip armour plates quite as well as you'd think it would, although ultimately the decision is yours, I'd think long and hard before trading those 2 for it, the other guy is definitely getting the better deal

[Claydough]

Both are excellent weapons for different reasons.

The dancing lady will have great dps, but only if you are hitting crits.

[KingNephilim]

I never understood the chase for a carving knife myself. Like was mentioned above, since no mods can be added it makes the syn useless. If you want a sword for pvp (which is understandable... swords are awesome in pvp) just get a friend to take you into arena a few times & then purchase a charge blade. Then you'd get to keep both guns & have a sword.

[Kuroro]

charge blade?can be used without dlcs?i cant buy dlcs,dats why i really want a carving knife.and i have a feaster fully t4 moded,i think that the feaster and the carving knife in the same loadout for pvp would be great...