also, one thing I just noticed. a lot of people who seem to be really enjoying this game, time after time say they really enjoy playing with friends. I play on PC, and primarily play games by myself. One of the great joys of MMOs is that you can meet other people (without having your IRL buddies own the game) and befriend them and play with them. That is one thing that Defiance is missing and possibly why some people are having much less of an enjoyable time. The people who seem to be digging it the most, do in fact have other friends that play. I do not, and I grow bored trekking through the forgotten bay area by my lonesome.
okay, aside from CoD being in this, I just lost a lot of faith in what you have to say. BF3 and Crysis are not simply point shoot. CoD, yes. BL2, yes. But, there is a difference in the other two games. There is more strategy than the common shooter. It has more gratification because of the complexity, and at least CoD lets you prestige 1000 times, which gives people a semblance of accomplishment. But, this is greatly more simplified than BF3.