What rating would you give Defiance the game out of 10?

[Jack Johnson]

In it's current state: A solid 7~7.5 with room to improve depending on what's in the DLCs.

Going with this. Lack of endgame, bugs, and a number of other issues hold it down, but otherwise I find the core gameplay enjoyable. I said I wouldn't keep doing random encounters with the keys removed, but I often still find myself rolling out the door of my orange dodge charger to fight random Dark Matter enemies... fragging them feels good, much like fragging Cerberus goons did in Mass Effect 3.

[Ngamok]

I personally would give it a 7/10

Same here.

[Gohlar]

4/10

Was sold as a tpsmmo and has no compelling group content and I'm not into checking off boxes in a hud which is all there really is to do. It saddens me to see people pretend this is content.

[NicodemusTNT]

The game is enjoyable, but I can only give it a 6. I don't care if it is an MMO or not, this is buggier and has more problems than a Bethesda release. By the time it is all sorted out, the community may be rather small. When you don't start out with a dedicated fanbase, you need to come out strong from the start. It also scares me that Sledge is posting less and less, which leads me to believe he is less optimistic about fixes. I hope they can fix the issues, because this game could be a solid 9.

[Jack Johnson]

I don't care if it is an MMO or not, this is buggier and has more problems than a Bethesda release.

I've had a character rollback, but I've never had my file become corrupted and have to start from the very beginning. My poor friend played the PS3 version of Skyrim, and if he went an hour without a bug, it was a miracle. So no, that's a nice hyperbole, but it did not have more bugs than a Bethesda release.

[Sull]

I would have given the game 7/10 despite the downtime and bugs until I got to San Fran. After that - and especially now that the main story is over - it would be 6/10. The past two nights have been dreadfully boring, full of broken co-ops and rinse and repeat arkfalls to gain some random blue or green bound-to-be-broken-down-to-resources items. Not a gripe, as I did enjoy the game and I can see its promise. However, there is no "end game" content really, which is kind of needed considering the game did not take all that much to "finish" at this point. I enjoy tooling around on the vehicles though...the physics are a lot of fun to play with. But you can only do that so long before it, too, gets tedious. I'm hopeful (as a season pass purchaser) that the DLC is robust.

If they put in a few end game dungeon-type raid instances very soon (with apt rewards - no green shields, thanks) then I'll play that contently. I have enough checklists in life to do, I don't need another set of them in a game I use to escape with. Just my two pennies.

[Seal]

Best gameplay and most fun and engaging shooter and MMO I've tried in a long time. I normally don't like to solo at all, but this game has me rolling solo most of the time, because it is simply that much fun.

10/10 because I've been completely surprised by this game and although the bugs are major and many, it doesn't even come close to ruining my experience with the game so far.

[Jack Johnson]

If they put in a few end game dungeon-type raid instances very soon (with apt rewards - no green shields, thanks) then I'll play that contently.

Everyone I've talked to IRL or in-game has agreed that at the very least hardmode instances would go a LONG way. I mean, shtako, look at heroics from Burning Crusade. Minimal effort for several months of content.

[Napalm Sunrise]

6 pre patch. 5 post patch.

^^^THIS. The only thing keeping me going is some Pursuits (i really don't know why i have such an obsession with collecting them) and the combat. The rest is just atrocious especially because of the new bugs introduced and many old ones not REALLY being fixed.

[HanPL]

5/10 after patch.
Patch was around 4gb and I see no changes in game at all.
No wait Hotshot Damm Defence is back but all other things are still bugged (Like freaking reloading bug )