+ Reply to Thread
Page 3 of 9 FirstFirst 1 2 3 4 5 ... LastLast
Results 21 to 30 of 81
  1. #21
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2013
    Location
    Albany NY
    Posts
    1,620
    Quote Originally Posted by ironlungz949 View Post
    slarg your weapon is a nice beast
    where to start........
    Synergy: Survivalist
    [2] +2% damage to targets with full health and shields
    is a nice synergy when aired up with another survivalist synergy weapon

    the 8% damage next shot after a kill combined with crit mult mag and fire rate make this a very deadly weapon
    the nade on kill is very nice touch to this weapon.
    since this AR works wonderfull at long and mid range, i see the melee dmg bonus as a unnecessary bonus to this beast

    i would have to vote:
    NO
    I also have to Vote No on this one, However.... this is still a Titan in every respect of the term.
    I agree with the Melee being out of sorts here. The vibe I get from this gun is that of a mid ranged focused killing machine. You have your superior fire rate, a bonus on kills (nade and damage), and a crit bonus. If the Melee had been crit or fire rate, and the syn was outlaw, I could vote yes.

    Saying no really sucks, but I did also say no to my own two titans for much the same reasons

  2. #22
    Member
    Join Date
    May 2013
    Location
    Seattle
    Posts
    666
    vbi assult rifle umodded yet but all slots open
    poop shoes
    ego 2100
    survivalist
    xp bonus 8% damage next shot after kill
    x1.25 melle
    -0.30 accuracy
    10% ego recharge on crit kill
    1.25 mag


    vbi assualt rifle fully modded with synergy match
    assassin
    ego 1829
    electric
    xp bonus 8% damage next shot after kill
    x.85 reload
    -0.30 accuracy
    25% of stowed reloaded on kill
    x1.10 firerate


    frc nomad
    ego 2274
    electric machinist less damage while reloading un modded gotta open slots
    xp bonus 15% crit from the hit
    1.25 mag
    -0.10 recoil
    10% ego recharge on crit kill
    x1.25 mag
    Psn K-E-Y-M-A-S-T-A
    Clan PASSPORT2HELL
    Current wants
    Defiance on next gen
    New dance moves
    More whiskey

  3. #23
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Apr 2013
    Posts
    845
    Quoted from the other thread:
    I have to say No to the Tachmag, No to the VBI

    The tachmag loses too much from that 10% bonus from last shot in clip. Its an AMAZING gun and one of the best titans but not an Optimum Creatio. we have to be picky with high standards. This is very close though, this is probably the BEST titan I would ever judge without calling it an OC.

    The VBI is not even close to me. Wayy to much crappy recoil reduction on a gun with basically no recoil without any reduction already. It doesn't need it. The synergy is solid but doesn't compliment the stats and it doesn't flow together to set the weapon over the top. 10% faster reload and two rolls devoted to recoil reduction are not ideal.

    Judges, be PICKY. Lets not start letting every gun into the optimum creatio category and start the issue all over again! These do not qualify IMO
    I also say no to SSlargs VBI Rifle clearly, horrid synergy and a melee bonus just doesn't work for the OC category.

  4. #24
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Apr 2013
    Posts
    845
    vbi assult rifle umodded yet but all slots open
    poop shoes
    ego 2100
    survivalist
    xp bonus 8% damage next shot after kill
    x1.25 melle
    -0.30 accuracy
    10% ego recharge on crit kill
    1.25 mag
    I won't ever vote yes on a poop shoes OC gun. Melee bonus also holds it back as does survivalist synergy. Survivalist can work for a titan gun but not an OC.

    vbi assualt rifle fully modded with synergy match
    assassin
    ego 1829
    electric
    xp bonus 8% damage next shot after kill
    x.85 reload
    -0.30 accuracy
    25% of stowed reloaded on kill
    x1.10 firerate
    This is extremely hard to say because this is SUCH an amazing gun but no to this. Only because, as good as the synergy is, and as solid as the bonuses and the nano is, they don't mesh together to form a sort of perfect storm. With assassin you'd prefer at least one crit bonus or a 10% ego recharge on crit kill, maybe even also a weapon exp bonus of 8% ego extended on crit kill. This is the VERY closest Titan to an OC i have seen yet but I have to say no.

    frc nomad
    ego 2274
    electric machinist less damage while reloading un modded gotta open slots
    xp bonus 15% crit from the hit
    1.25 mag
    -0.10 recoil
    10% ego recharge on crit kill
    x1.25 mag
    WHYYYYY MACHINIST SYNERGY! If it had a better synergy this gun was about to become an OC. as it is, I have to say no. Again, another amazing titan gun of yours.

  5. #25
    Senior Member ironlungz949's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2013
    Location
    Alexis Texas
    Posts
    2,483
    vbi assult rifle umodded yet but all slots open
    poop shoes
    ego 2100
    survivalist
    xp bonus 8% damage next shot after kill
    x1.25 melle
    -0.30 accuracy
    10% ego recharge on crit kill
    1.25 mag

    *** my vote is NO***
    You have a mid to long range weapon, and when you have that melee bonus there, it kills the chances of this weapon to be a Optimum Creatio

    vbi assualt rifle fully modded with synergy match
    assassin
    ego 1829
    electric
    xp bonus 8% damage next shot after kill
    x.85 reload
    -0.30 accuracy
    25% of stowed reloaded on kill
    x1.10 firerate

    *** my vote is YES***
    this weapon is meant to deal damage on a killing scale, you kill you get a dmg bonus make that shot count with a critical
    assassin synergy makes it deadly and i think this is a really great titan with no flaws

    frc nomad
    ego 2274
    electric machinist less damage while reloading un modded gotta open slots
    xp bonus 15% crit from the hit
    1.25 mag
    -0.10 recoil
    10% ego recharge on crit kill
    x1.25 mag

    *** my vote is NO***
    the nomad is amazing but the synergy restricts its capabilities to yo having to equip another synergy weapon type. also bc its a equip synergy, you lose out on a chance to get a extra synergy like assassin granedier and cannoneer would...
    the synergy kinda holds it back
    PSN: Catintheoven (NA servers)
    Character Name: Alexis Texas

  6. #26
    Member
    Join Date
    May 2013
    Location
    Seattle
    Posts
    666
    You guys think the bio ar and the nomad are titans?
    Psn K-E-Y-M-A-S-T-A
    Clan PASSPORT2HELL
    Current wants
    Defiance on next gen
    New dance moves
    More whiskey

  7. #27
    Senior Member ironlungz949's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2013
    Location
    Alexis Texas
    Posts
    2,483
    Quote Originally Posted by KEYMASTA View Post
    You guys think the bio ar and the nomad are titans?
    yes they are both titans my friend
    PSN: Catintheoven (NA servers)
    Character Name: Alexis Texas

  8. #28
    Senior Member ironlungz949's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2013
    Location
    Alexis Texas
    Posts
    2,483
    updated keymasta final decision
    PSN: Catintheoven (NA servers)
    Character Name: Alexis Texas

  9. #29
    I would say yes on my vote for magics ar
    Member of The Collectors

    Holder of the Titan Weapon "The Sweet Tooth"

    In Game name Beta Raybill

    PSN MFGabrish08

  10. #30
    Senior Member Zabuza's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2013
    Posts
    1,120
    Quote Originally Posted by TravelerX1 View Post
    Thanks for the added info Olaf!
    Given the nearly full Mod set. With the Ionic Barrel in place - I would have no issue dubbing this an OC. (aka holding my final decision until ya get the barrel, LOL)

    What this has going for it:
    -Perfect Syn for the Weapon Type
    -Great Nano also for the Weapon Type and build style
    -Perfect storm of Synergy, Bonuses, and Mods in both Mag size and Accuracy with a side of Crit Bonus.
    -Clearly a weapon that would excel on every field of battle without a doubt.

    If you get a chance, I would love to see the post-mod stats of it. Mainly the Bloom and crit mult after the barrel mod.

    ------------------------------------------------

    Updated info from Olaf: With the Barrel - Crit is now x2 and Bloom is 0.13

    So..... This Judge Votes....

    This gun is a OC Candidate. Vote: Yes
    No it isn't. Mastery Stat is horrible for an SMG. It is Near Perfect by the guide lines.

    I judge that you should not be a judge of such things.
    In-Game: Ghost Bear
    Degeneration X
    PSN(NA): PEWPMONGER

    Quote Originally Posted by Warcurse View Post
    Defiance Dating Services is a RIDICULOUS concept I know...but not MORE ridiculous than selling, complaining threads so WTH. If your a single lady in Chester county PA and would like to discuss Defiance over dinner and drinks hit me up n I'll send ya a pic
    Quote Originally Posted by Ryzaerian View Post
    Even Everlast, in his House of Pain days, once mused "you make me sick, like Strawberry Quik.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts